Death Cab for Cutie Setlist at Summerfest 2012

They didn't play Talking Bird last night, the song was Lightness.

I'm 100% sure it was Why You'd Want to Live Here.

The lyrics "At St. Peter's cathedral
There is stained glass
There's a steeple that is reaching
Up towards the heavens
Such ambition never failing to amaze me" aren't in Why You'd Want To Live Here. I'm 100% sure, it's St. Peter's Cathedral, bro. I have footage.

I'm not gonna get into it with you. If you want the setlist to be wrong, that's cool, put St. Peter's Cathedral.

Here's my painfully ignorant two cents: Why You'd Want To Live Here was definitely played. I made a note here to myself that though I didn't know the third encore, that it was a song "about LA." Listening to it now, I recognize it from last night. However! I do also remember catching the words 'St. Peter's Cathedral' being sung at some point in the show and thinking, 'Isn't that the name of one of their songs? Maybe that's what this song is.' (I've never heard it.) Plus, you know, if CaptainUltimate has video of it you can't argue with that. Are you sure you're not both right?

I know St. Peter's was sandwiched in the encore somewhere, but I, personally, don't remember Why You'd Want To Live Here, but I'm not going to argue with it if everyone else does. Blacking Out The Friction might be the problem, but I'll leave it to everyone else.

Is it possible they had a snippet of SPC within "Why'd You Want to Live Here"? A mashup of sorts? That could be.

They definitely played "St. Peter's Cathedral," "Why You'd Want to Live Here," and "Blacking out the Friction." If I remember correctly, SPC was sandwiched between the two.

I've gone ahead and edited the setlist to add St. Peter's Cathedral into the encores like wroday described. Then when or if anyone can confirm exactly how the encores were arranged they can adjust it, but at least everyone's memory is accounted for in the mean time.

This looks right.