History: Evanescence Perform “My Immortal” for the First Time

On November 4, 2000, Evanescence took the stage at River Market Pavilions in Little Rock, Arkansas, for a performance that would become a significant moment in the band's early history. Among the songs performed that evening was “My Immortal,” marking the song's first documented live performance, nearly three years before it would become one of the band's signature hits.

At the time, Evanescence was still a relatively unknown act emerging from the Little Rock music scene. The lineup for the performance featured Amy Lee on vocals, Ben Moody on guitar and vocals, David Hodges on piano, keyboards and vocals, Matt Outlaw on drums, Nick Williams on bass and Stephanie Pierce on backing vocals. John LeCompt is also believed to have performed on guitar, although his participation remains unconfirmed.

Evanescence 11.4.2000 - Little Rock, Arkansas – By IcadoZoyiee via evanescencereference.info

The eight-song setlist offered an early glimpse into the band's developing sound, featuring “Whisper,” “Even in Death,” “Imaginary,” “Where Will You Go,” “My Immortal,” “Lies,” “Away From Me” and “Anywhere.” Several of these tracks were featured on the band's early independent release, Origin, while “Whisper,” “Imaginary” and “My Immortal” would later appear on their breakthrough debut studio album, Fallen, in 2003.

Despite eventually becoming a staple of Evanescence's live shows, “My Immortal” was rarely performed during the band's earliest years. According to Setlist.fm records, the song was performed just once in 2000, at the November 4 show, and only once again in 2001, during a February 3 performance at TNT Powerhouse in Little Rock.

The song would not appear on another documented setlist until 2003, when Evanescence released Fallen and catapulted to international fame. The album, which featured breakout hits “Bring Me to Life,” “Going Under” and “My Immortal,” would eventually earn Diamond certification in the United States. That year, “My Immortal” appeared on 38 recorded setlists, beginning its transformation from an early rarity into a concert favorite.

More than two decades later, “My Immortal” ranks as Evanescence's fourth most-performed song of all time, trailing only “Bring Me to Life,” “Imaginary” and “Going Under.” Its journey from a rarely performed early composition to one of the band's most enduring live staples makes that November 2000 performance a particularly memorable piece of Evanescence history.

Evanescence recently wrapped up their North American and European tour dates for their most recent album, Sanctuary, in late October, but the band still has a full slate of appearances ahead. Fans can find additional information and stay up to date on upcoming performances through the band's official tour website.


Upcoming Show Dates

November 28 – Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia – National Hockey Stadium

December 1 – Tokyo, Japan – SGC Hall Ariake

December 2 – Tokyo, Japan – SGC Hall Ariake

December 4 – Osaka, Japan – Zepp Osaka Bayside

January 16 – Inglewood, CA – Kia Forum (ALTer EGO 2027)

March 5 – Perth, Australia – RAC Arena

March 7 – Adelaide, Australia – Adelaide Entertainment Centre

March 9 – Melbourne, Australia – Rod Laver Arena

March 10 – Melbourne, Australia – Rod Laver Arena

March 12 – Sydney, Australia – Afterpay Arena

March 16 – Brisbane, Australia – Brisbane Entertainment Centre

March 20 – Auckland, New Zealand – Spark Arena

June 5 – Nuremberg, Germany – Rock im Park

June 6 – Nürburg, Germany – Rock am Ring

June 10 – Nickelsdorf, Austria – Nova Rock

June 11 – Interlaken, Switzerland – Greenfield Festival


Karma Police - Please Share:

Most played songs

Last updated: 9 Nov 2026, 13:42 UTC

More from Evanescence


16,219 attendances by 11,865 users.