Apr 29 2018

Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness Setlist at Irving Plaza, New York, NY, USA

Tour: Pen And The Piano Tour statistics Add setlist

Song played from tape

Mister Rogers Theme

Play Video
Love and Great Buildings

Play Video
I'm Ready

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Punk Rock Princess

(Something Corporate cover)
Play Video
No Man Is an Island

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Andrew and Zac Clark
Canyon Moon

Play Video
High Dive

(Bob Oxblood joined during song)
Play Video
Andrew, Zac Clark and Bob Oxblood
Bruised

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
The Resolution

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
As You Sleep

(Something Corporate cover)
Play Video
Fire Escape

Play Video
Bob Oxblood and Zac Clark
Flowers on Time

(Bob Oxblood cover)
Play Video
Love You Later

(Zac Clark cover)
Play Video
Stay

(Bob Oxblood cover)
Play Video
Zac Clark and Allen Stone
Don't Just Love Me Cause You're Lonely

(Zac Clark cover)
Play Video
Andrew, Zac Clark and Bob Oxblood
Swim

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Walking in My Sleep

Play Video
Maps for the Getaway

Play Video
Song played from tape

Interlude

(Allen Stone as Babe Ruth)
Ohio

Play Video
I Woke Up in a Car

(Something Corporate cover)
Play Video
Andrew and Allen Stone
Where You're At

(Allen Stone cover)
Play Video
Allen Stone
Upside

(Allen Stone cover)
Play Video
Give You Blue

(Allen Stone cover)
Play Video
Allen Stone and Bob Oxblood
Killing Time

(Allen Stone cover)
Play Video
Zac Clark, Allen Stone, Bob Oxblood
I Know That I Wasn't Right

(Allen Stone cover)
Play Video
Mountains

(Zac Clark cover)
Play Video
All Performers
Dark Blue

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Dead Man's Dollar

Play Video
La La Lie

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Encore:
Restless Dream

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Summer Breeze

(Seals & Crofts cover)
Play Video
Cecilia and the Satellite

Play Video
Holiday From Real

(Jack’s Mannequin cover)
Play Video
Song played from tape

Mister Rogers Theme

Play Video

Edits and Comments

14 activities (last edit by leglessmoof, 19 Jul 2023, 20:57 UTC)

Show edits and comments

Songs on Albums

Covers 23
- As You Sleep by Something Corporate
- Bruised by Jack’s Mannequin
- Dark Blue by Jack’s Mannequin
- Don't Just Love Me Cause You're Lonely by Zac Clark
- Flowers on Time by Bob Oxblood
- Give You Blue by Allen Stone
- Holiday From Real by Jack’s Mannequin
- I Know That I Wasn't Right by Allen Stone
- I Woke Up in a Car by Something Corporate
- I'm Ready by Jack’s Mannequin
- Killing Time by Allen Stone
- La La Lie by Jack’s Mannequin
- Love You Later by Zac Clark
- Mountains by Zac Clark
- No Man Is an Island by Jack’s Mannequin
- Punk Rock Princess by Something Corporate
- Restless Dream by Jack’s Mannequin
- Stay by Bob Oxblood
- Summer Breeze by Seals & Crofts
- Swim by Jack’s Mannequin
- The Resolution by Jack’s Mannequin
- Upside by Allen Stone
- Where You're At by Allen Stone
Others 5
Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness 4

Tour stats

Complete Album stats

Last updated: 12 Jun 2025, 22:49 UTC

Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness Gig Timeline

Apr 26 2018

9:30 Club Washington, DC, USA Add time

Add time
Apr 28 2018

Warsaw Brooklyn, NY, USA Add time

Add time
Apr 29 2018

Irving Plaza This Setlist New York, NY, USA Add time

Add time
May 01 2018

The Jefferson Theater Charlottesville, VA, USA Add time

Add time
May 02 2018

Buckhead Theatre Atlanta, GA, USA Add time

Add time

Last updated: 12 Jun 2025, 22:49 UTC

Share or embed this setlist

Use this setlist for your event review and get all updates automatically!

HTML Code

<div style="text-align: center;" class="setlistImage"><a href="https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/andrew-mcmahon-in-the-wilderness/2018/irving-plaza-new-york-ny-5bec773c.html" title="Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness Setlist Irving Plaza, New York, NY, USA 2018, Pen And The Piano" target="_blank"><img src="https://www.setlist.fm/widgets/setlist-image-v1?id=5bec773c" alt="Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness Setlist Irving Plaza, New York, NY, USA 2018, Pen And The Piano" style="border: 0;" /></a> <div><a href="https://www.setlist.fm/edit?setlist=5bec773c&step=song">Edit this setlist</a> | <a href="https://www.setlist.fm/setlists/andrew-mcmahon-in-the-wilderness-3bf8a474.html">More Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness setlists</a></div></div>

Last.fm Event Review

[url=https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/andrew-mcmahon-in-the-wilderness/2018/irving-plaza-new-york-ny-5bec773c.html][img]https://www.setlist.fm/widgets/setlist-image-v1?id=5bec773c[/img][/url] [url=https://www.setlist.fm/edit?setlist=5bec773c&step=song]Edit this setlist[/url] | [url=https://www.setlist.fm/setlists/andrew-mcmahon-in-the-wilderness-3bf8a474.html]More Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness setlists[/url]

Customize your setlist.fm widget