Songs
- A Thousand Days (1)
- All About Love (5)
- All Is Well (1)
- All Night Long / Never Gonna Give You Up / Alone (1)
- At This Moment (1)
- Back For More (1)
- Breaking Up Is Hard to Do (1)
- Bridge Over Troubled Water (4)
- Build Me Up Buttercup (1)
- California Gurls (1)
- Can't Take My Eyes Off You (1)
- Can't Touch This / Black Velvet / End Of The Road / Iris / Livin' La Vida Loca (1)
- Car Wash / December 1963 (Oh What A Night) / September / Nights On Broadway / Too Much Heaven / I Feel The Earth Move (1)
- Carolina in My Mind (4)
- Celebrate Me Home (2)
- Christmas Serenade (1)
- Christmastime (2)
- Die Moritat von Mackie Messer ("Mack the Knife") (1)
- Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me (1)
- Don’t Save It All for Christmas Day (4)
- Even Now (1)
- Everlasting Love (1)
- Fields of Gold (4)
- Good News (1)
- Grease (1)
- Grown-Up Christmas List (4)
- Hark the Herald Angels Sing (1)
- Hark the Herald Angels Sing / O Come All Ye Faithful (3)
- Hark the Herald Angels Sing / O Come All Ye Faithful (1)
- Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas (4)
- Here, There and Everywhere (1)
- I Can't Help Myself (Sugar Pie Honey Bunch) (1)
- I Can't Make You Love Me (1)
- I Could Not Ask for More (1)
- I Knew You Were Waiting (2)
- I Miss You Most at Christmastime (1)
- I Survived You (7)
- I Will Always Love You (1)
- I Will Carry You (8)
- I Will Carry You / The Way / When You Say You Love Me (1)
- I'll Be Home for Christmas (If Only in My Dreams) (1)
- In My Life (1)
- Invisible (13)
- Jesus Is Love (1)
- Jesus, Born on This Day (1)
- Jingle Bells (2)
- Kyrie (6)
- Kyrie Eleison (2)
- Love Me Tender / Hound Dog / Blue Suede Shoes / Don't Be Cruel / Heartbreak Hotel / Jailhouse Rock / Can't Help Falling in Love (1)
- Love, Love, Love (1)
- Mack the Knife (1)
- Mandy (1)
- Mary, Did You Know (4)
- Measure of a Man (7)
- Measure of a Man / Fields of Gold (1)
- Measure of a Man / Fields of Gold / When I Need You / Carolina In My Mind (1)
- Merry Christmas With Love (4)
- Miss independent (1)
- Miss You Most (at Christmas Time) (1)
- Misty (1)
- Moon River (1)
- No More Sad Songs (6)
- O Come O Come Emmanuel (3)
- O Holy Night (3)
- On the Wings of Love (1)
- Open Arms (4)
- Perfect Day (8)
- Rock With You (1)
- Rosanna (2)
- Run to Me (2)
- Sailing (1)
- Sending You a Little Christmas (1)
- Silent Night (1)
- Silver Bells (3)
- Sleigh Ride (4)
- Solitaire (5)
- Someone Else's Star (1)
- Somewhere Out There (1)
- Still the One (2)
- Suspicious Minds (1)
- Suspicious Minds / Daydream Believer / Downtown / Can't Buy Me Love / Sugar Sugar / So Happy Together (1)
- Sweet Baby James (2)
- Tell Her About It (1)
- The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire) (3)
- The Christmas Waltz (4)
- The First Noel (4)
- The Music of Christmas (1)
- The Season for Romance (1)
- The Way (7)
- The Way / This Is the Night / Measure of a Man / A Thousand Days / On My Way Here / Invisible (1)
- This Is the Night (3)
- To Love Somebody (1)
- Twisting the Night Away / At the Hop / Johnny B Goode / Rockin Robin / The Great Pretender / Only You / Mr. Sandman / That'll be the Day / Great Balls of Fire / Rock and Roll is Here to Stay (1)
- Unchained Melody (3)
- Vincent (1)
- What Are You Doing New Year's Eve (1)
- When Doves Cry (7)
- When I Need Love (1)
- When I Need You (3)
- When You Say You Love Me (8)
- Where Did Our Love Go? / Midnight Train To Georgia / My Girl / Tears of a Clown / Rescue Me / I Heard It through The Grapevine / Reach Out (I'll be There) / Think / Ain't No Mountain High Enough (1)
- Where the Streets Have No Name (2)
- Who's Sorry Now (1)
- Winter Wonderland (2)
- Without You (7)
- You Were There (2)
How Can You Mend a Broken Heart performed by Clay Aiken
This song currently isn't used in any Clay Aiken setlist.