Songs

(What's So Funny 'Bout) Peace, Love and Understanding (1)
A Change Is Gonna Come (1)
A Gospel Number (27)
Abdulmajid (1)
After All We've Been Through (29)
Afternoon Delight (1)
Afterthought (1)
Against the Grain (32)
Ain't No Sunshine (18)
All I Ever Get for Christmas Is Blue (121)
All I Need Is Everything (338)
All My Favorite People (172)
All of It Was Music (21)
All Over Ohio (35)
Amelia's Last (20)
An American in Belfast (1)
And Can It Be (38)
Angel Band (10)
Angelina Baker (1)
Angels We Have Heard on High (2)
Another Christmas (18)
Anything at All (126)
Anyway (49)
Auld Lang Syne (1)
B.P.D. (71)
Baby If This Is Nowhere (57)
Baby, It's Cold Outside (6)
Bass Solo (1)
Bella Luna (42)
Bethlehem (2)
Betting On the Muse (30)
Bill (1)
Birds (43)
Blood Oranges in the Snow (36)
Blue Jean Sky (34)
Bluebird (1)
Bluer (24)
Born (290)
Bothered (177)
Broken Angels (91)
Called Home (70)
Calling All Angels (3)
Cast Me Away (44)
Cast Me Away / And Can It Be (12)
Changes Come (56)
Charles (1)
Christmas Concerto (1)
Christmas Time Is Here (1)
Church Basement (1)
Circle of Quiet (61)
Come Rain or Come Shine (1)
Conjectures of a Guilty Bystander (19)
Cruel and Pretty (127)
Cuatro Solo (1)
Curse These Dreams (14)
Cuyahoga (13)
Daddy Untwisted (22)
Dancing Queen (1)
Danny Boy (1)
Darlin' (1)
Darlin' (Christmas Is Coming) (30)
Days Like This (23)
Dayton, Ohio -- 1903 (1)
Dead Weight (2)
Desperate for Love (22)
Don't Wait for Tom (69)
Don’t Let the Bastards Get You Down (5)
Dreams (1)
Drum Solo (1)
Drunkard's Prayer (186)
Earthbound Love Song (62)
Entertaining Angels (1)
Entertaining Thoughts (50)
Etcetera Whatever (114)
Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere (4)
Everybody Wants to Feel Like You (2)
Everyman's Daughter (42)
Eyes Wide Open (10)
Fairpoint Diary (38)
Faithfully Dangerous (216)
Falling (Death of a Tree) (2)
Fantasia on Greensleeves (1)
Farther Along (1)
Favorite Time of Light (32)
Fever (76)
Firefly (43)
First Snowfall (56)
Flanders Fields (1)
Fly Dance (17)
Fool (4)
Fruit of My Labor (1)
Gentle Wounds (4)
Give Me Strength (33)
Given Road (33)
Go Down Easy (83)
God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen (1)
Gonna Let My Soul Catch My Body (98)
Goodbye (This Is Not Goodbye) (87)
Goodbye Charles (29)
Green-Clouded Swallowtail (30)
Greensleeves (5)
Grey Monologue (2)
Half Moon Halo (7)
Hallelujah (12)
Happy Birthday to You (4)
Happy to Be So (9)
Happy With Myself? (25)
Happy Xmas (War Is Over) (2)
Hard Times Come Again No More (4)
Hark! The Herald Angels Sing (1)
Harvest Moon (1)
Have You Ever Seen the Rain? (1)
Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas (12)
HDIF (Reprise) (23)
Helpless (6)
Here It Is (30)
Heron Blue (46)
Highland County (14)
Hirondelle (2)
Holly Went Out Walking (3)
Holy Fool (1)
Holy Rain (20)
Hometown Boy (44)
Honey, You Don't Know My Mind (7)
Honeybee (1)
How Can I Keep From Singing? (6)
How Does It Feel (To Be on My Mind) (25)
How Great Thou Art (1)
How Long Have You Been Stoned (8)
Hungry Heart (2)
Hurt (7)
Hush Now (Stella's Tarantella) (99)
I Can't Help It (If I'm Still in Love With You) (2)
I Don't Wanna Waste Your Time (147)
I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day (1)
I Just Want to Be With You (4)
I Let It Go (7)
I Painted My Name (23)
I Radio Heaven (73)
I Say I Do (1)
I Shall Be Released (4)
I Want You to Be My Love (94)
I Will Always Love You (1)
I Will Not Eat the Darkness (6)
I Will Remember (16)
I'd Want You (100)
I'll Be Home for Christmas (If Only in My Dreams) (4)
I'm on a Roll (126)
I'm Wrapping Up My Love (1)
I've Been Slipping (4)
I've Got a Crush on You (1)
Idea #21 (Not Too Late) (6)
If a Song Could Be President (75)
If I'm Drowning (31)
If Nothing Else (61)
If We Make It Through December (38)
Il Est Dans Mon Poche (12)
Indoor Fireworks (1)
Infamous Love Song (32)
Iron Curtain (10)
Is It Too Late to Start? (7)
It Came Upon the Midnight Clear (38)
It Makes No Difference (11)
It's Never Quite What It Seems (15)
It's Ok to Say Goodbye on a Good Day (6)
It's Only a Paper Moon (9)
Jack's Valentine (138)
Jacksie (32)
Jesus in New Orleans (76)
Jig Newton (4)
Jingle Bells (6)
June (55)
Just a Song Before I Go (2)
Lasso (1)
Last Night (21)
Last Night on Earth Again (6)
Latter Days (301)
Layers (3)
Leaning on the Everlasting Arms (2)
Leavin' Days (12)
Let It Be (8)
Let It Fall (83)
Let the Lower Lights Be Burning (1)
Let You Down (68)
Let's Spend the Day in Bed (27)
Lifelong Fling (38)
Like a Radio (65)
Lilac Wine (3)
Little Blue River (87)
Little Blue River/In the Garden (37)
Little Did I Know (45)
Little Genius (14)
Little Girl Blue (2)
Little Town (9)
Lonely Girls (2)
Long Lost Brother (65)
Long May You Run (1)
Look at Miss Ohio (5)
Lookin' Forward (56)
Los Lunas (29)
Love & Revelation (10)
Lovers in a Dangerous Time (1)
Lucy (92)
Lucy and the Reverend (1)
Lullabye (9)
Making Pictures (19)
Mary's Waltz (53)
May God Love You (Like You've Never Been Loved) (47)
Meet Me at the Edge of the World (80)
Melancholy Room (20)
Mercy Now (1)
Merry Christmas, Baby (2)
Merry Go Round (2)
Miles (42)
Moon River (7)
Moondance (24)
Moth (64)
Mrs. Robinson (4)
Mudlarking (1)
My City Was Gone (4)
My Father's Body (30)
My Funny Valentine (12)
My Love Is a Fever (150)
Nature Boy (1)
Nature Boy (3)
Needle and the Bruise (4)
New Redemption Song (32)
New Year's Song (6)
Night and Day (6)
Night of Silence (1)
No Kill Shelter (26)
Nobody Number One (38)
North Pole Man (77)
Nothin' (11)
Nothing Is Innocent (59)
Now I Know (13)
O Come, O Come, Emmanuel (1)
O Little Town of Bethlehem (1)
Oh Marie (1)
Oh Yeah By the Way (30)
Ohio (164)
One of a Kind (4)
One Olive Jingle (3)
Only God Can Save Us Now (52)
Ophelia (1)
Orphan Girl (142)
Over You (10)
Paper Wings (1)
Paul and Virginia (41)
Piano Solo (1)
Pilgrim (3)
Please Father Christmas (2)
Poughkeepsie (181)
Professional Daydreamer (60)
Purple Rain (1)
Rave On (41)
Remind Us (15)
Rhapsodie (49)
Rocking Chair (14)
Sacred Ground (138)
Sea and Sky (37)
Shaking and Trembling (1)
Sharp Cutting Wings (Song to a Poet) (3)
Sharpest Blade (6)
She (46)
She Lost Feeling in the Ends of Her Fingers (1)
Should (6)
Show Me (90)
Silent Night (57)
Sister (1)
Sleep Baby Jane (24)
Snow Angel (38)
Snowed in With You (7)
Some Kind of Amazing (2)
Someday (1)
Someone I Used to Know (2)
Sometimes I Feel Like a Motherless Child (9)
Son of a Preacher Man (12)
Songbird (14)
Soon (10)
Spark (53)
Spinning (21)
Spoken Word (1)
Stormy Weather (1)
Suitcase (173)
Summer's End (1)
Summertime (48)
Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This) (1)
Thank You My Angel (30)
The Arms of One Good Love (1)
The Bluebird (poem) (4)
The Body Is a Stairway of Skin (9)
The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire) (17)
The First Noel (1)
The Genius of Water (21)
The King Knows How (56)
The Laugh of Recognition (80)
The Love of God (8)
The Man I Keep Hid (1)
The One I Love (6)
The Oxen (3)
The Poopsmith (2)
The Seahorse (164)
The Trumpet Child (86)
The World Can Wait (123)
There's a Bluebird in My Heart (22)
This Daring Light (3)
Through The Mexican Border (1)
Toledo (21)
Trouble (279)
Ubiquitous Hands (12)
Undamned (36)
Unspoken (8)
Up North Here Where the Stars...1945 (2)
Uphill (1)
Wait (35)
Watching the Wheels (4)
We Three Kings (1)
We're Gonna Pull Through (62)
What a Wonderful World (11)
What I'll Remember Most (19)
Whatever You Say (17)
When I Go (136)
When You Say Love (1)
White Horse (36)
Who Will Guard the Door (15)
Who'm I Kiddin' but Me (90)
Wildflower Bouquet (18)
Willoughby (9)
Within Without (51)
Words (1)
Worryin' Ain't Worth the Trouble (6)
You Can't Fail Me Now (1)
You'd Be So Easy to Love (1)

It's Never Quite What It Seems performed by Over the Rhine

From the release Good Dog Bad Dog: The Home Recordings (Album)
Total Plays 15 times by Over the Rhine
15 times by 1 artist
First Played in Concert March 20, 1999 at Canal Street Tavern, Dayton, OH, USA
Most Recently Played November 8, 2025 at Nowhere Else, Martinsville, OH, USA

Report a problem: Report song

Years

	Year	Song Performances
1	1999	6


2	2000	4


3	2023	3


4	2010	1


	2025	1