Hey, your message on my page: "Hi there! I've got something i'm curious about, on the latest Oasis setlist, you said that one of the songs that Noel sang doesn't need a tag saying Noel on vocals, yet several rolling stones songs that have Keith on vocals on both studio and live version have it, so I was curious where the line is drawn on whether it should be noted, plus it'll be good to know for future editing, thank you"
Take a look at all the other times Oasis has performed those songs where Noel is on lead vocal in the studio. Since Noel sings them on the studio recording and "every" time they perfom it live, the note isn't needed as that's the default for the performance. Noel's live lead vocals on songs Liam normally sings lead on (studio and live) would be noted. Or when Liam was absent from a song he normally sings, or a show where he didn't perform, etc.
Similar to how we don't put "Stevie Nicks on lead vocal" every time Fleetwood Mac performs "Landslide" at a show. If Christine McVie had taken over lead vocals for "Landslide" at a F.M. show, THAT would be noted. Same goes for "Songbird" in reverse - Christine McVie's song studio & live, no vocal info note needed on setlists unless another member of Fleetwood Mac sang it instead of C.M.
Same for the Eagles - not noted when Don Henley or Glenn Frey sing live lead vocals on the songs they also sing lead vocals on the studio recordings.
Re: the Rolling Stones I was not aware that users were adding "Keith Richards on lead vocals" info notes on songs Keith recorded lead vocals on and "always" performs lead vocals on live. At some point, a topic should be started in the forum, inviting Stones' Superfans to the topic to discuss why this info note isn't needed and should be removed. Vs. just removing them all and then 100s of users are alerted to edits made on new and old setlists, and revert wars start, etc.
Hey, your message on my page:
"Hi there! I've got something i'm curious about, on the latest Oasis setlist, you said that one of the songs that Noel sang doesn't need a tag saying Noel on vocals, yet several rolling stones songs that have Keith on vocals on both studio and live version have it, so I was curious where the line is drawn on whether it should be noted, plus it'll be good to know for future editing, thank you"
Take a look at all the other times Oasis has performed those songs where Noel is on lead vocal in the studio. Since Noel sings them on the studio recording and "every" time they perfom it live, the note isn't needed as that's the default for the performance. Noel's live lead vocals on songs Liam normally sings lead on (studio and live) would be noted. Or when Liam was absent from a song he normally sings, or a show where he didn't perform, etc.
Similar to how we don't put "Stevie Nicks on lead vocal" every time Fleetwood Mac performs "Landslide" at a show. If Christine McVie had taken over lead vocals for "Landslide" at a F.M. show, THAT would be noted. Same goes for "Songbird" in reverse - Christine McVie's song studio & live, no vocal info note needed on setlists unless another member of Fleetwood Mac sang it instead of C.M.
Same for the Eagles - not noted when Don Henley or Glenn Frey sing live lead vocals on the songs they also sing lead vocals on the studio recordings.
Re: the Rolling Stones
I was not aware that users were adding "Keith Richards on lead vocals" info notes on songs Keith recorded lead vocals on and "always" performs lead vocals on live.
At some point, a topic should be started in the forum, inviting Stones' Superfans to the topic to discuss why this info note isn't needed and should be removed.
Vs. just removing them all and then 100s of users are alerted to edits made on new and old setlists, and revert wars start, etc.