Mr_Gig's setlist.fm

Mr_Gig's user profile image

About

Activity

Member since October 8, 2013
Last seen September 21, 2022
Edits so far 5214
Edits last month 195

Comments

Please sign in to comment.
You can also connect with Facebook or Twitter.

Thank you. Now the Demon set looks right. Appreciated

In my opinion Focus 1 is just a renaming of Focus, so should be considered a cover technically. Since we use the original name or first release on this site there shouldn't be a mention of "Focus 1" on here.
It's not because an expert claims he sees things differently that the guidelines on here shouldn't be respected.
E.g. as European or American you drive on the right side of the street, but when you go to the UK, Japan and Australia? you apply to the rules there :)

Hi there,
I noticed you mentioned just what you did on setlists to bypass the mandatory edit comment feature.
https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/dead-lord/2022/kavka-zappa-antwerp-belgium-63898e4b.html#sfmsesg33cff899
https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#sources
"Be sure to explain why you edited the setlist. Don't explain what you've edited as this is obvious to the viewer."
Setlist.fm is a wiki-effort, and it is important for us all to be as transparent and clear as possible in sharing information. To ensure that edits are verified for other users, and to avoid unnecessary discussions and save a lot of time in the future, edit comments have been made mandatory for all users.
https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#sources
Please ensure that you share informative comment with future edits, so that everybody understands where you received the information you're contributing.
Thanks!

Hi Erwan,

I tend to agree with you about the Grand Slam songs, and I did wonder about it at the time.

As I recall, all of the previous Grand Slam 'Artist Statistics' had credited 'Military Man' to Gary Moore and 'Dedication' to Thin Lizzy, so when I added a new setlist, it was auto-corrected by Setlist.fm to include the 'cover' info. When I subsequently looked at the Grand Slam artist stats, I saw only one setlist that was out-of-step with all of the others, and that must have been the one you added. I think I only edited 'Military Man' but it auto-corrected 'Dedication' at the same time.

If you contact the moderator Oddi, and convince them, they can do a batch edit for all the Grand Slam setlists. I was not aware of the official release of 'Live at Nostell Priory 1984' as included in 'The Collection' boxset listed on Discogs; that provides a particularly strong case.

Cheers,

B

Thanks for updating the 2016 NWOBHM setlists. Much appreciated. I updated what I could, but I was a bit drunk that weekend !!

Hi Mr Gig, I've seen your last update about Dismember's "Deranged from blood" and it appears you are right. But there are other entries of this song attributed to Carnage.

Beside, what about Nihilist songs attributed to Entombed, for example ?
https://www.setlist.fm/stats/albums/entombed-13d699d5.html

We're discussing about Oh Well, and might come up with an unexpected solution.

User charts

Mr_Gig saw 1437 different artists.

1 Steve Hackett 17
2 Judas Priest 15
3 Uli Jon Roth 14
4 Satan 13
5 Accept 12
  Tygers of Pan Tang 12
7 Michael Schenker 11
  Saxon 11
9 FM 10
  Tytan 10