rreett's setlist.fm
About
Attended Concerts
Comments
Please sign in to comment.
You can also connect with Facebook or Twitter.
Hello! Sorry for the delayed response! Haha I'd hardly call myself the main authority; I'm just a fan of the band's work. You've done more for the band's setlists on here than anyone else I've seen in recent years! And I'd be happy to share my opinion on a few things!
1. Upon listening to the recording, I would say that it should be listed as a note rather than as an individual song. It was more of a brief tease than anything else. This site has a section of guidelines for snippets that's really helpful to reference in situations like this: https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#setlistSnippets
2. Any arrangement that isn't based on the studio version from 3-Way Tie (For Last) and/or is drastically different from it should be noted, I think. I would consult this set of the site's guidelines regarding additional information that can be added as song notes: https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#infos
3. I believe the latter of your suggestions would be the correct one. The song was released on What Makes a Man Start Fires? as "East Wind/Faith", and because the songs all have to be listed under their officially released titles, just adding a note pointing out that the first half of the song was omitted is the best solution. I encountered a similar situation a few years ago with Neutral Milk Hotel's song, "The King of Carrot Flowers, Pts. Two & Three", where only Part Three was played at most 1996-97 shows.
4. Yes, I saw that you made those edits! Even though I've listened to the recording that's featured on Ballot Results plenty of times, I could never figure out what that song was. I always thought it was some sort of a live improv or maybe an unreleased song of theirs. Thank you for figuring out what it actually was! :)
Though I don’t have Fantômas setlists, I have pics of the setlists used for the Secret Chiefs 3 East Brunswick and Corner Hotel shows that have the unreleased ‘New Ishraqiyun’ song listed as ‘Afghan(m?)’ if they are of any use.
I don’t think I have any pics of Fantômas setlists, I was just a mad live show trader of Fantômas, Melvins, SecretChiefs3, Mr.Bungle in those days.
I don’t know how Fantômas listed Delirium Cordia parts on setlists, but Patton said they would be playing ’sections’ live (as opposed to entire album) in an interview when Delirium Cordia was being released…
Sorry I can’t help more!
Hahaha it's totally all right! I really appreciate your well wishes, and I hope the new year is treating you and your loved ones well! :) Regarding "Bumper Sticker Commercial", since it wasn't an actual song, but a scheduled break in their set where they passed out bumper stickers and encouraged fans to put them around town, I think the best course of action to take is to add an intermission in its place and include a note with it explaining what the band was doing. I can make that edit after I post this comment.