livemusicfan's setlist.fm

About

Activity

Member since October 25, 2012
Last seen November 25, 2020
Edits so far 151704
Edits last month 390

Comments

Please sign in to comment.
You can also connect with Facebook or Twitter.

Ok then. If you want to act like a troll then I'll treat you like a troll. Don't bother making any more edits.

Hi livemusicfan,
did you see my comment to Nov. 5 Stu Allen show re. the bifurcation of the ‘Terrapin Crossroads’ venue to ‘Beach Park’ and ‘Grate Room’ tags?
The new distinction only goes back a year, and is rather redundant. I’ve spent a lot of time adding Terrapin setlists - I don’t see good enough reason to go back to hundreds of shows 2012 through 2019 and split them into Grate Room or Beach Park so they agree. Much more efficient, and I think detailed enough to take the handful of recently split tags and change them all to ‘Terrapin Crossroads’.
As I wrote before, this also resolves any confusion of the shows that started in Grate Room and moved out for a set in the Park. Before you going changing more venue tags, I hope you’ll think about it. Wish we’d connected at Sam Holt in Nashville!

Please take a look at our guidelines on sources: https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#sources

"It is mandatory to add sources to all of your edits. Not only can your edit be verified for other users, it can also avoid unnecessary discussions and save a lot of time."

"Be sure to explain why you edited the setlist. Don't explain what you've edited as this is obvious to the viewer. For example "added a song" is not a valid source. Examples for valid sources are (among others):

Links to official websites (e.g. artists posting their setlists on their websites)
Links to social media channels (e.g. fans posting images of the setlist)
Links to setlist scans
Links to videos of the concert
"I was there" - if you were at the concert and remember the song being played"

Notice the word "link" for anything you didn't attend. If you refuse to post a link with your edit we'll have to consider you a troll who can't follow a simple rule.

A suggestion
When correcting a songtitle e.g. on https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/gordon-lightfoot/1978/bayfront-center-st-petersburg-fl-b8769ca.html#sfmses7328d601 as a source you write Corrected songtitle. In my opinion this isn't a valuable source. If I would write 'dejazedpijezd' and tell as a source Corrected songtitle would this proof my point.
Solution may be you use https://www.setlist.fm/stats/songs/gordon-lightfoot-73d6ba9d.html?song=Christian+Island+%28Georgian+Bay%29 as proof where the song was played 232 times before.

Saw you changed the name of the tour for the tour in 2012 - but here's the actual press release from Jackson Browne website. https://www.jacksonbrowne.com/news/jackson-browne-announces-summer-2012-u-s-acoustic-tour-with-special-guest-sara-watkins/

Hi, I read your comment on Ben's page. Changing back to the old way is explained in the FAQ: https://www.setlist.fm/faq#newEditor. But you could do us a huge favour and tell us why you want to switch back, this will help improve the new edit form. Thanks!

I really don't know. I know it is different on different platforms/devices. I'm still using the old system myself. I think your best bet would be to post on one of the Forum topics like the "General..." or "Suggestions" one. If I see something definite I'll let you know tho.
Cheers,
Ben

Okay, so what's the story? You removed all of the 'reprises' by putting it in the @Info (because the songs were being counted twice) and now you are removing it from the @Info and putting it back the way it was... why?

Please read the guidelines for posting sources:

https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#sources

Any edit without a clickable link can/will be deleted or reverted. Thanks.

I will put info on the venue page mentioning it's actual physical location.

If you really think it should be listed in Geneva Township I can do that too. You know the region better than I do.

Google Geneva, MN and check the map. Then Google Geneva township and look at the map. Harmony Park is on the west shore of Geneva Lake where it narrows. It is in the Township of Geneva, not in the city of Geneva.

Harmony Park is not in the city of Geneva which is what "Geneva, MN" denotes on this website. The venue is actually in the "Townside of Geneva" with a Clarks Grove mailing address. For some reason the venue address was listed here as "Ellendale" which was completely wrong. The venue could plausibly be listed as being in Clarks Grove or the Township of Geneva. We have no set rule when dealing with these situations. Because the venue is already listed, its webpage uses Clarks Grove and it is physically in an unincorporated township I am leaving it in Clarks Grove. If it was a PO Box I would definitely change it. I haven't gotten to Fur Peace yet.

Hello

Is there a difference between Max's on Broadway and Max's On Broadway for which you just changed the venue for the Posies concert?
If it's the same venue you should report this to the forum https://www.setlist.fm/forum/setlistfm/website-support/problems-with-venues-3bd6bc4c to have one deleted.

I only transferred them to CD, so far.

Hey Now,
Got the Radz info from the DATs of the shows that I have. ;-)

I tried to edit the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame info for the jam, but it gave me a too long error. Anyway, missing are Chuck D & Reverend Run.

To be honest with you I don't really know how it was decided. It was tried a while back and had some bugs. It got rolled out with some of the much needed and welcome updates implemented earlier this year. It's not something I find particularly useful and the Comments or @Info seemed satisfactory to me too. And I'm sure we will have to deal with Users fighting over whether the show ran 1:43 or 1:49. I would say that contacting an Admin or starting a Forum topic would be best.

I went to the Elvin Bishop/Charlie Musselwhite show tonight. They announced recording a new album together that will be out sometime this summer.

Once it's officially on Amazon or elsewhere, can make "Elvin Bishop & Charlie Musselwhite" a musicbrainz artist entry are re-title these shows properly.

Shame I couldn't see the Byrne show in person!

I'd say that if you know the room I would use it. I find that there are times when casino rooms use different names without any "official" name change or use slightly different name like "The Buzz Room/Buzz Room/The Buzz/Buzz Club" for the same venue. Sometimes I think it is better to just use the generic casino name for them. But there is no hard and fast rule.

User charts