Comments
Please sign in to comment.
You can also connect with Facebook or Twitter.
Feel free to write to me if it becomes an edit war. I'll first try to find a political consensus about the final edit and the reasons of it. If that doesn't work I can block the involved user to prevent future edits on that specific setlists
I was looking for it as an Oasis song, and found it in Andy Bell's setlists.
I also saw the comments that you mentioned.
Question about the song:
Do you if it was later recorded by Andy Bell as a solo artist?
I ask this because we have this rule about covers
"Exception 1
If a songwriter writes a song for another artist or group which they were not a part of, and never records their own version of the song, then the song should be credited to the artist who released it first. If the songwriter does finally release their own version of the song, regardless of how many years have gone by, then the song should be credited back to the songwriter. E.g. "Bright Eyes" was written by Mike Batt and first released by Art Garfunkel in 1979. Mike Batt released his version in 2009, so the song is credited back to him."
In this case, if the song was only recorded by Oasis is an Oasis song. If later Bell recorded it own version, it will considered it song.
Hi earivas,
Thanks for reaching!
Do you have an example of these changes over the song "Thank You for The Good Times"?
Musicbrainz is similar to setlist.fm in that you can get an account and make edits to the database. Your propose an edit with your supporting evidence, and it is put to a vote by the active membership, similar to the process used on discogs. If approved, it is incorporated into the database. I'm not sure whether that gets automatically pulled into setlist.fm, or if you need to post to the forum here to ask a Moderator to do it manually. But once that happens, a Moderator can propagate the change using EventMonkey.
I'm not sure why some people here don't take the time to fully describe their edits. I appreciate how frustrating it is to do a lot of research just to get smacked down without explanation. But we need people like you who really care about the database, so I hope you will persist.
Our conversations with KRArchives have convinced us that they have valid information about the band, including the knowlege of where the photos were taken. We have a few Users on this site who have established their credibility in those ways, and we give those people some extra leeway for sources (for example, not all pictures are available online with a clear location mentioned).
That doesn't mean that anything goes, but if we have a problem with their sources, we will revert their edits ourselves. Please do not engage in edit wars, especially on setlists where you have already entered assumed songs.
If they are not responding to your advice, you can report them to the mods:
https://www.setlist.fm/forum/setlistfm/website-support/spam-troll-user-3d6b9df?page=135
No problem man. Thanks for changing it back. That guy is still insisting it’s a cover but he’s wrong.
You are correct on buckcherry it is not a cover but an adaptation
Great posting the Howard Jones show. Did Midge Ure sing with Howard on the Christmas song? Worth noting if so...
bq. Coalminor is maliciously reverting a set list that I am updating live at the show. Please advise
OK, but be aware to make your homework better when you make even slightly changes for an artist on several setlists. A setlist may change during the course of a tour, so find sources for each, not some general article about one show where you conclude the setlist didn't change. Also when people who attended list the song as New (which already started to be sung from 2013 on) don't assume it's some unknown song (which would have been listed as Unknown Song - see my remark from November last year).
Otherwise people would have used Unknown song as written on your profile page last November.
There is NO Paul McCartney song called "New". People added that as a placement since they did not know the name of the song was "Queenie Eye" which is on Paul's latest release.
thank you
Better do your homework before making assumptions.
He even released a CD called New 9 years ago.
https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/4247618e-45af-4080-95f0-43e1a7d77ea6
McCartney "New" song title was added per https://www.justjared.com/2022/05/14/paul-mccartneys-got-back-tour-2022-set-list-revealed/
I made the changes without the citation BEFORE getting your email. Please feel free to unlock and I will update accordingly.
thank you
As you can see by the various comments of attendees Queenie Eye was performed on the setlist you changed. You found a source where New was performed. The tour lasts 15 dates (one still to be performed) on which New and Queenie Eye were performed
https://www.setlist.fm/stats/paul-mccartney-13d6bd15.html?tour=bdefd76
The newspaper article spoke indeed about the Los Angeles performance where New was performed.
https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/paul-mccartney/2022/sofi-stadium-inglewood-ca-5bb7d3c8.html
Hello
You keep on changing several Paul McCartney setlists without any real source, just telling new song added.
All have been locked now because you don't seem to read the reason for my reverts.
If one doesn't recognise a song there is a possibility to add this . Read https://www.setlist.fm/guidelines#unknownSongs
https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/the-orchestra/2021/klein-strand-ostend-belgium-3b8cd82c.html#sfmsesg73c78685
thnx Bendobrin.. The fact is that when I keyed in the title of the song, setlist.fm automatically filled in the link to the Kinks reference. Perhaps, we should consider why setlist did that and I did not make that specific association.
Please review the Guidelines for cover songs. The song was first released as a Dave Davies solo single as indicated by provided link that is accurate. And our Roadies actually do know quite a bit about these things so you should be careful to make sure your information is correct when changing their edits. We all make mistakes, but I think everyone involved here is just trying to get this right so there doesn't seem to be a big problem,
https://www.kindakinks.net/discography/showrelease.php?release=120
Hello about the REO Classics. I had set up a set list with just Terry Luttrell's name which came up when making it. You can see if it still works. But it seemed it was replaced. So I am not sure if a admin can adjust or do we go to musicbrain to adjust.